Page 1 of 2

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:28
by djp73
I have a bit of a QB battle conundrum going into my first season at USF, here are their ratings:
NameYearOVRSPDACCAGICODSTRAWRTHPSACMACDACRUNTUPBSKPACCARBCVJKMSPMBTKSFATRKIBLSTATGHINJ
HSO(RS)7973777977728788828077847667728281726873657242928789
BSO(RS)7777808484707286868078797680796658576366615948878688
SSO(RS)7677758177727087827978857182818084807476707649908487
FFR(RS)6971797373627590817769666355646465444443433425918780
CFR(RS)6985868588616384716867776981617979877673606145978484
DFR6677837872525777786676737764676460745848494435818078

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:29
by djp73
H is the front runner, I dont like the lower SAC but he can hit drags and crosses fine so it seems ok so far. He is the returning starter who had a great year last season so probably the pick from a realism standpoint, but I was not the coach last season.
B has the athleticism I like to have at my disposal but I am worried about fumbles and it doesn't look like he will be making many defenders miss or be plowing them over.
S is an incoming transfer who had a good season at Georgia State. Again a little lower on accuracy and not as athletic as B but looks like he can get out of sacks and fight off tacklers better.

Who would you start? How would you determine a starter? Vibes? Scientific? Would you go into the season with a three man rotation?

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:30
by redsox907
schedule a cupcake in Week 1, play all of em for a quarter each, and see who feels the best

:pause:

but that's what I always do. Also, give them each 5 reps with 5 of your go-to plays in Practice mode. Sliders don't transfer over into practice, but at least you can see who fits your style better

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:34
by Caesar
B has the best accuracy. B is the answer.

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:39
by djp73
Caesar wrote:
Yesterday, 16:34
B has the best accuracy. B is the answer.
SAC he does, I'm calling MAC and DAC a push

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:40
by djp73
redsox907 wrote:
Yesterday, 16:30
schedule a cupcake in Week 1, play all of em for a quarter each, and see who feels the best

:pause:

but that's what I always do. Also, give them each 5 reps with 5 of your go-to plays in Practice mode. Sliders don't transfer over into practice, but at least you can see who fits your style better
I have run a ton of plays in practice and can't see much separation tbqh :shrug:
I think giving them all some run in our first game, not a cupcake unfortunately, is the move.

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:42
by djp73
OH, I forgot
H and D are impact
the rest are normal

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:44
by Caesar
djp73 wrote:
Yesterday, 16:39
Caesar wrote:
Yesterday, 16:34
B has the best accuracy. B is the answer.
SAC he does, I'm calling MAC and DAC a push
According to the Interwebz, "short passes" are up to 20 yards which will be like what? 75% of your throws?

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:57
by djp73
Image Image
Image Image
Image Image

How do you handle Position battles?

Posted: 08 Nov 2025, 16:58
by djp73
I hope I can keep Duff